Is Keir Starmer on the verge of a remarkable comeback, or are the whispers of his downfall growing louder? Dive into this exclusive chat with the UK's Prime Minister, where optimism clashes with stark political realities— and you'll be hooked by the twists that could reshape British politics.
By
Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg
'By 2027, I'll still be right here in this chair,' Sir Keir Starmer joked during our chat, even hinting that if things went smoothly, he might extend an invitation for a follow-up interview inside Downing Street next year.
Leaders like prime ministers rarely get a real break. Just before our conversation, Sir Keir had been on the phone with Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelensky, puzzling over the dramatic events in Venezuela where his close political ally, US President Donald Trump, launched an attack and detained the country's leader, Nicolás Maduro. By the end of our extended interview, Maduro had already faced charges in New York.
As we kick off the new year, Sir Keir appears rejuvenated—perhaps from some downtime with his family at Chequers, the traditional countryside retreat for British prime ministers. This seems to have lifted his mood compared to the rough patch he endured toward the end of 2025, a year filled with political turmoil for him.
But here's where it gets controversial: Are Starmer and his supporters fooling themselves by believing his luck is about to change?
Image source, Reuters
The harsh reality is that a significant number of his Labour Party colleagues view him as ineffective at his role. In fact, some are eager to take a risk and push for his removal as early as this year.
Yet, in our Saturday morning discussion, Sir Keir firmly rejected these ideas. He repeatedly emphasized that he'd 'be evaluated at the next general election,' declaring that no one could strip away his five-year term—even if switching leaders might be the best shot at preventing Nigel Farage and Reform UK from reaching Number 10.
'This is the battle of our era, and I'm committed to leading the charge,' he stated confidently.
Image source, PA Media
The challenge for the Prime Minister is that judgments will come much sooner, during the massive set of elections in May across the UK. He insisted, maybe a tad too emphatically, that these votes focus on local councils and regional governments in Scotland and Wales—not directly on the national Parliament at Westminster.
That's partially true, of course. But even if Sir Keir doesn't want to acknowledge it, the results will undoubtedly reflect on Downing Street's performance too.
Despite this, he made it clear there was no scenario where he'd step aside, even if a fellow Labour MP challenged his position following a poor electoral outcome for the party.
Image source, Reuters
To explain his current unpopularity, Starmer pointed out that the public is naturally eager for quicker improvements, assuring me—and you—that 2026 will mark a real shift. He predicted economic growth would pick up, despite ongoing unemployment issues, as the government's early policies from their turbulent first year start to pay off.
He also pledged to shut down asylum hotels ahead of the 2029 deadline, though he avoided naming a specific date. Additionally, while not guaranteeing success, he expressed hope that a peace agreement in Ukraine now seems more attainable than at any time since Russia's full invasion began. For the first time, he shared that Western nations are discussing ways to combine US and European military efforts to secure Ukraine post-conflict.
His main takeaway for everyone? That we're on the cusp of 'turning a corner' this year.
Image source, Reuters
Starmer came across with more vitality during our talk than I've noticed in a while—seemingly more at ease and with ample time to elaborate. Still, amid demands from various quarters for a more assertive strategy, with stronger leadership, faster action, and greater urgency, his responses echoed familiar themes.
When faced with such deep political woes, does he need a fresh approach? And this is the part most people miss: No administration, especially one struggling with popularity for months on end, can achieve everything effortlessly.
Starmer's difficulties stem not only from the inherent challenges of governing but also from errors made by him and his team, including recent missteps.
Image source, Reuters
He admitted regretting his enthusiastic welcome of Egyptian-British activist Alaa Abd El Fattah back to the UK after backlash over resurfaced comments, such as his calls for violence against Zionists and police. Starmer attributed the oversight to 'the system' failing to flag these issues beforehand—a more polished way of saying it wasn't his responsibility.
As the year progresses, he's walking into clear political minefields. His relationship with the US President, for instance, becomes riskier following Trump's actions in Venezuela. Having spoken with Starmer—a seasoned human rights lawyer who once opposed the Iraq War—over many years, the notion that he'd endorse such maneuvers feels downright improbable.
Image source, Getty Images
He described himself as a 'dedicated champion of international law' but noted that 'we don't have the complete facts yet.' Some were calling for him to denounce the events before our interview, and it's likely the government will face intense scrutiny in Parliament soon to clarify their stance.
There's also simmering tension within Labour to reconsider or reverse aspects of Brexit—the UK's decision to leave the European Union in 2016, which led to new trade and immigration rules. For beginners, Brexit fundamentally altered how the UK interacts with Europe, often causing economic and political debates.
Starmer denies any reversal, but his fresh pledge to strengthen ties with the European single market—the vast trading bloc in Europe—could spark outrage from those accusing him of reneging on his promise to respect Brexit outcomes. This move might delight some in his party, but it's ripe ammunition for Reform and Conservatives to claim he's betraying his word.
Image source, Getty Images
Last year, Starmer faced criticism for being overly pessimistic. He's clearly aiming for a brighter outlook now. Yet, with his problems running so deep, many critics—and perhaps even some allies behind closed doors—might find his upbeat tone this weekend a bit out of sync. As a cautious leader, he remarked: 'I always come with caveats.'
His backers praise this as wise stability, while opponents argue it reveals a lack of the sharp intuition top politicians need.
This weekend, the Prime Minister insists he'll weather the storm and that prosperity is just around the bend. But—and here's the big caveat—he can't ensure his party or the electorate will buy into that vision.
Top image: Getty Images
BBC InDepth (https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/bbcindepth) is your go-to spot on the website and app for top-notch analysis, offering fresh viewpoints that question the status quo and in-depth coverage of today's major stories. Sign up now for alerts on new InDepth pieces—click here to learn how. (https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cj6x46j8g5do)
- Kemi Badenoch (https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/topics/c2jq3dqjmk5t)
- Keir Starmer (https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/topics/c50znx8v8rwt)
- Labour Party (https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/topics/crr7mlg0dg1t)
What do you think—does Starmer deserve to stay on as leader despite the challenges, or is it time for a change? And on the Brexit front, is aligning more with the single market a smart strategic move or a betrayal of democratic decisions? Share your thoughts in the comments below—let's debate!
